Many natural toothpastes will not protect teeth from cavities

Natural, herbal, and organic toothpastes are increasingly common on store shelves, where they are promoted as a healthier alternative to conventional products. Some contain aloe vera, neem, or green tea. But before you switch to a different toothpaste, it’s worth asking one important question: does it contain fluoride?

Many natural toothpastes will not protect teeth from cavities

Fluoride is a mineral that helps protect teeth from cavities. Some toothpastes marketed as natural contain it, while others do not. The labels on the front of the tube do not indicate whether the product will protect our teeth.

These terms are often used interchangeably, although they mean different things. “Natural” usually describes ingredients of natural origin, “herbal” refers to plant‑based components, and “organic” refers to ingredients produced according to specific agricultural standards. None of these labels on their own indicates that the toothpaste can prevent tooth decay.

A 2021 study from the UK examined 500 toothpastes from 95 brands, including alternative formats such as tooth powders and solid paste tablets. Almost a third did not contain fluoride, and some did not clearly indicate its content. Since the study covered only products that are on the market, it cannot show how many people actually use toothpastes without fluoride.

Caries begins when bacteria in dental plaque — a sticky film that builds up on teeth — feed on sugars from food and drinks. They produce acids that damage the enamel, the hard outer layer of the tooth. Over time, this can lead to holes, i.e., carious cavities.

Fluoride helps the enamel resist acids and repair early damage before a cavity forms. Its benefits have been confirmed by decades of research. The 2019 Cochrane review, which combined the results of 96 studies, showed that brushing with fluoride‑containing toothpaste reduces tooth decay compared to toothpaste without fluoride. Reviews collect data from multiple studies to assess the overall picture of the evidence.

Nevertheless, people sometimes switch to fluoride‑free products, believing that natural ingredients are necessarily safer or healthier. A 2019 letter in the British Dental Journal described the case of a dental student who developed several carious cavities after switching to an organic toothpaste without fluoride. The student also had other risk factors: a habit of snacking on sweet foods and infrequent visits to the dentist. This isolated case does not prove that the organic toothpaste caused multiple caries, but it clearly shows why it is important to check for the presence of fluoride, even for those who brush their teeth regularly.

Some toothpastes and mouthwashes contain plant extracts: green tea, aloe vera, neem — a tree traditionally used for oral hygiene in South Asia. These ingredients may help control bacteria and gum inflammation — gingivitis, which causes redness, swelling, and bleeding when brushing.

A 2024 review of previous studies suggested that some herbal oral care products, especially mouthwashes, may reduce plaque and gum inflammation as effectively as conventional products. However, many studies were short, and their methods and results varied — this makes it difficult to understand how well specific ingredients work over time.

Reducing plaque and gum inflammation is good, but it doesn’t prove that the toothpaste prevents cavities. There is insufficient evidence that herbal ingredients can replace the proven protection of fluoride against cavities. The toothpaste may contain both plant‑based components and fluoride, so consumers don’t have to choose between them.

Another product that is often sold as natural, especially for whitening, is charcoal paste. A 2023 review found limited evidence that charcoal pastes whiten teeth better than other options. Most studies also indicate that they may be more abrasive: they can wear down the tooth surface through friction. However, most studies were conducted in laboratories, so they cannot determine how much wear occurs during everyday use.

The easiest way is to check the fluoride concentration on the packaging. In the UK, NHS recommendations state that adults should use toothpaste with a fluoride content of at least 1350 ppm (parts per million) — that is, a minimum of 1,150 parts of fluoride per million parts of toothpaste.

Children need their own concentration and quantity. The NHS recommends using toothpaste with a fluoride content of at least 1,000 ppm for children under 3 years of age, in the amount of a dab on the bristles. For children aged 3–6 years, a pea‑sized amount of toothpaste with a fluoride content of 1,000–1,500 ppm. From the age of 7, the recommended concentration is 1350–1500 ppm.

It is beneficial to brush your teeth twice a day for about two minutes each time, including the last time before going to bed, and after brushing, spit out the excess toothpaste without rinsing immediately with water. This way, fluoride stays on the teeth longer.

Natural ingredients can play a useful role in oral care, and better long‑term studies could clarify their benefits. Regardless of what the toothpaste contains, an appropriate amount of fluoride remains one of the simplest and most cost‑effective ways to protect teeth today.

Published

November, 2026

Updated

Category

Medicine

Duration of reading

4-5 min

Share

Global health science — in clear language

We select and translate the best international publications. Read 3 key materials about longevity every week!

Send us a message