The form of psychological protection against existential horror depends on the cultural and religious ideas prevailing in society. Representatives of Asian culture are characterized by fatalism as a form of mitigating the fear of death. Fatalism means the belief that many events in life are beyond a person’s control: first of all, such key moments as birth, marriage, illness, and death. One study
examined the reactions of Asian Americans to the loss of loved ones after the 9/11 attacks. Speaking about their feelings, they were more likely than the victims belonging to Western culture to say that this loss was “in the hands of God,” “beyond my control,” and viewed the sad events as “part of something bigger” and “the natural course of things.” In another
study, Chinese-born Australians explained the causes of cancerous tumors by talking about “karma,” “retribution,” “the will of heaven,” “the hand of God.”
The researchers note that the concept of “karma” is often used by native speakers of Asian culture when explaining the causes of adverse events. Karma refers to “paying for mistakes” made in “past lives” and “correct” behavior in the present moment in order to avoid retribution in “future lives.” Thus, the concept of karma is closely related to the belief in reincarnation – the
transmigration of the soul from one body to another, which in the framework of the theory of fear of death management can be considered as one of the “projects of immortality.”
A study
conducted at the National Defense University (Taipei, Taiwan) aimed to discover a link between belief in karma and fear of death. 64 Taiwanese students participated in the experiment. During the study, the participants were divided into two groups: students from the first group were “immersed” in thoughts of death at the beginning of the study. Next, the participants were invited to familiarize themselves with the story, the hero of which saved the animal from death, after which he “miraculously escaped mortal danger.” Then they suggested evaluating several statements of a “fatalistic” nature on an eight-point scale, for example, “everything that happens in life is predetermined by fate,” “only what should happen happens,” “wealth and fame are in the hands of God,” etc.
The study showed that participants who reflected on death rated fatalistic statements higher, and also demonstrated greater faith in karmic predestination. For comparison, during this experiment, a group of American students studying in Taiwan were included in the study. After completing similar tasks, participants from the United States showed much less faith in fate and karmic retribution, and the situation did not change even after thinking about the inevitable death. According to scientists, these results demonstrate that belief in karma and fatalism can be seen as symbolic ways of protecting people with an “Asian mentality” from the fear of death.
In addition, some features of “Oriental” people have been discovered concerning such a concept as self-esteem, which is closely related to the importance of a person in society and allows him to “join” the projects of immortality that this society professes. This question is relevant for individualistic “Western” cultures that recognize the value of an individual.
A study
conducted in Japan showed that it is more important for representatives of this country not to prove their importance by towering over their fellow citizens, but to feel like part of a collective of a certain social stratum with strict rules of behavior and a clear hierarchy. Instead of emphasizing their value and individuality, people tend to “merge” with a significant group, to feel like a part of the whole. Therefore, it is not self-affirmation that will act as a protective mechanism against existential anxiety for a Japanese person, but rather the ability to “keep your face”, follow the rules, regardless of circumstances and feelings.